PSY-5107 Week 3 – Assignment: Develop a Good Research Question with Chosen Variables and Related Hypotheses
PSY-5107 Week 3 – Assignment: Develop a Good Research Question with Chosen Variables and Related Hypotheses
Research Question and Variables
When developing research, there are essential elements that make up a good research topic. These include independent and dependent variables, which are the parameters that need to be investigated in the research. Additionally, a good research question must have all the requirements of a scientific research question. The purpose of this assignment is to describe independent and dependent variables and develop a good research question.
Variables
Independent variables are measures that the researcher can control or manipulate and they often come first in the research question (Gravetter & Forzano, 2018). In my inquiry, the topic is to investigate the relationship between maternal factors of age, income level, education level and the risk of obesity in infants. For example, the independent variables in my topic are maternal factors of age, income, and education level. The dependent variable is a measure that the researcher has no control over, and it often comes towards the end of the research question (Gravetter & Forzano, 2018). The dependent variable in the topic is the risk of infant/child obesity. Validity refers to the extent to which the research results present accurate findings. Variability is the absence of consistency. There is a concern for variability, which might occur with the research if the results from different participants are not consistent (Lee et al., 2018).
Research Question
Weak: What do the maternal factors of age, income, and education have in common with the infant’s risk of obesity?
Improved: Do maternal factors of age, income, and education level have a strong correlation with the risk of infant/child obesity?
A research question must have five elements. The first element is falsifiable, which means a theory that can be proven to be untrue. The second element is that the question should be based on a topic that is worthwhile to study (Ratan et al., 2019). The third element is that the research question should reveal a relationship expected from the study. Finally, the research question should be possible to answer in one question.
Click here to ORDER an A++ paper from our Verified MASTERS and DOCTORATE WRITERS PSY-5107 Week 3 – Assignment: Develop a Good Research Question with Chosen Variables and Related Hypotheses:
The first question is vague and does not visibly indicate the possible relationship between the variables. The question does not reveal that the hypothesis can be proven to be false and also the expected relationship is not clearly demonstrated by the question (Vignero & Wenmackers, 2021). The second question which is more improved incorporates the five elements of a good research question. For example, the relationship can either be proven true or false at the end of the study. Similarly, the expected relationship is clearly outlined. Furthermore, the topic of study is important as it concerns the health outcomes of the pediatric population and obesity which is on the rise within this population, making it a major health problem. Finally, the improved question is answerable with only one study.
Hypothesis
Alternative: Maternal factors of income, age, and education level are associated with the risk of infant/childhood obesity.
Null: Maternal factors of age, income and education level are not associated with the risk of infant/childhood obesity.
Conclusion
Developing a research question requires an effective understanding of variables and the elements of the research question. A good research question should show the connection between the independent and the dependent variables. Furthermore, the question should be based on an important topic that is worth studying. Other important elements of the research question are falsifiable and testable in one study. Variables are either independent or dependent whereby independent variables can be manipulated by the researcher, but dependent variable is not modifiable.
PSY-5107 Week 3 – Assignment: Develop a Good Research Question with Chosen Variables and Related Hypotheses References
American Psychological Association. (2020). PsycLearn research methods [Computer software]. APA.
Gravetter, F. J., & Forzano, L. B. (2018). Research methods for the behavioral sciences (6th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Lee, Y., Hofferth, S., Flood, S., & Fisher, K. (2018). Reliability, Validity, and Variability of the Subjective Well-Being Questions in the 2010 American Time Use Survey. Soc Indic Res., 126(3):1355-1373. https://doi.10.1007/s11205-015-0923-8.
Ratan, S., Anand, T., & Ratan, J. (2019). Formulation of Research Question – Stepwise Approach. J Indian Assoc Pediatr Surg. 24(1):15-20. https://doi.10.4103/jiaps.JIAPS_76_18.
Vignero, L., & Wenmackers, S. (2021). Degrees of riskiness, falsifiability, and truthlikeness. Synthese, 199, 11729–11764. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-021-03310-5.
For your assignment this week, you will meet with your professor during an interactive live meeting. If you had difficulty scheduling your meeting, you might check to see if your professor holds regular office hours and find the time to attend then. If you are unable to meet with your professor, submit a written paper summarizing your responses as outlined below, including any questions you might have for your professor.
During this meeting, you will be asked to define, in your own words, what an independent and a dependent variable are, and how you can differentiate one from the other. Next, you will identify specific independent and dependent variables of interest within your topic of interest and why you selected these specific measures (reliability and validity might come into play here, so briefly define and describe these concepts and how they apply).
After clearly identifying and describing these variables, intentionally create a research question that needs some improvement (based on the five characteristics of good research questions that you read about this week in the PsycLearn module). To recap, these five characteristics include: a clearly defined relationship; variables of interest are described; the research can be conducted in a single study; the research question is falsifiable, and it is a worthwhile question. Once you provide a poor or weak research question, provide a stronger new and improved question, along with a brief analysis as to why this is a better research question to ask. Be sure to detail the five characteristics of a good research question in your response. Finally, conclude with a corresponding null and alternative hypothesis that directly aligns with your new and improved research question. Note that the null hypothesis should state that there is no effect, and the alternative hypothesis should state there is an effect in the direction that you expect.
Here is an example to help you to get a sense of what you want to do this week.
Research question (weak/poor): Is there is a connection between regular exercise and feeling good, as well as thinking clearly and enjoying life, and being happy?
Research question (stronger/improved): Is there is a strong positive correlation between getting regular exercise and self-reported measures of life satisfaction? (here, the relationship is more clearly defined).
Corresponding null hypothesis: There is no relationship between regular daily exercise of 30 minutes or more and self-reported measures of life satisfaction on the Life Satisfaction Ratings Scale (LSRS).
Corresponding alternative hypothesis: There is a significant positive correlation between regular daily exercise of 30 minutes or more and self-reported measures of life satisfaction on the Life Satisfaction Ratings Scale (LSRS).
Assemble these components in a Word file to prepare for your meeting. Here is a list to help you to remember to answer all parts of the questions this week. It is recommended you check off each item as you complete it for a thorough response.
Explain in your own words what an independent variable is, along with one that you want to explore more, and why it is important to do so.
Explain in your own words what a dependent variable is, along with one that you want to measure, and any concerns about reliability or validity.
Provide an intentionally weak research question using the identified independent and dependent variables.
Provide a new and improved version of this research question.
Describe the five characteristics of a good research question and how they are not all present in your original weak question but are present in your stronger new and improved version of your research question.
Provide a corresponding null and alternative hypothesis that aligns directly with your new and improved research question.
Length: 1-2 page summary of your work, along with a reference list
References: Include a minimum of 3 scholarly resources for your written response.
The completed assignment should address all of the assignment requirements, exhibit evidence of concept knowledge, and demonstrate thoughtful consideration of the content presented in the course. The writing should integrate scholarly resources, reflect academic expectations and current APA standards, and adhere to Northcentral University’s Academic Integrity Policy.
When applicable, conduct a Turnitin pre-check and then upload your completed assignment and click the Submit to Dropbox button.
WEEK 3
Independent versus Dependent Variables and Research Questions
As a scientist and a budding new researcher, you must determine what specific measures or variables you want to use for your research. For example, if you want to measure happiness, and you want to consider the different factors that might impact happiness, such as age, income, and marital status. In this example, you have different measures that you will take, or what researchers commonly refer to as variables. Broadly defined, variables are measurements that change over time (Gravetter & Foranzo, 2018).
When examining these different variables or measures, it is important to differentiate that there are separate categories or types of variables that researchers typically use. In most cases, these variables are designated as either independent or dependent (Gravetter & Foranzo, 2018). Independent variables are variables that the researcher intentionally changes or manipulates and controls, and they occur first in time during a research study, which is the principle of temporal contiguity.
On the other hand, dependent variables are the measures used to assess the impact of this intentional manipulation or change. They occur second in time and can be viewed as ‘dependent†on the changes in the independent variable. Explore the following information to learn more:
Launch in a separate window
For example, a true independent variable would be a study where the researcher intentionally randomly assigns participants to consume different samples of flavors of ice cream. The researcher then measures participants†self-reported likelihood of eating it again in the future using a Likert-type rating scale of 1 (not at all likely) to 10 (extremely likely). In this case, the different flavors of ice cream would be considered the true independent variable, or the variable that the researcher has total control over and is intentionally changing or manipulating in some way by randomly assigning subjects to consume these different flavors (Gravetter & Foranzo, 2018). The dependent variable in this example would be the subjects†self-reported ratings of the likelihood of eating that particular flavor of ice cream again in the future.
Figure 1
People May only Like Certain Flavors of Ice Cream
Now, put on your thinking cap, and start to think like a scientist. See if you can think of a few more examples of research studies that you would like to conduct, with clearly defined independent and dependent variables. Write these variables down, and then talk it over with your professor to determine if you are on the right track in terms of your ability to differentiate a true independent from a dependent variable. Just like most things in life, the more you practice at something, the better you will get – so give it a try!
Here is another example for you to consider. If you want to study happiness and try to figure out how income influences individuals†self-reported level of happiness (Santos, 2018), then, in this case, you can identify which variable is the independent variable and which one is the dependent variable. To help you figure this out, remember that an independent variable comes first in time. This type of variable or measure is often used to predict something else in the future. Did you get it right? In this case, income level is the independent variable that is being used to predict happiness. On the other hand, the dependent variable would be the variable that you are trying to predict in some way, and it occurs after the independent variable on the timeline. In this example, it would be the outcome measure of self-reported happiness. Another question to consider here: Is the variable of income considered a true independent variable or a quasi-independent one, and if so, why? A quasi-independent variable is a variable that the researcher is unable to randomly assign participants to. Take a moment to reflect on this, and then consider your answer.
Drum roll, please … If you said a ‘quasi†independent variable, then you are correct! Gold star for you! Remember, a quasi-experimental variable is a variable that the researcher does not have complete control over and cannot randomly assign subjects. Given that income level is not something that the researcher would have direct control over, this would be considered a quasi-independent variable, or a variable that is almost, but not quite, a true independent variable (Gravetter & Foranzo, 2018).
Now that you are clearer on the differences between an independent and a dependent variable and what a quasi-versus, a true independent variable looks like, it is important for you to also think about how you will define each of the variables you have identified for your hypothetical study, and to be certain that you are able to randomly assign subjects to the different levels of the independent variable (a true independent variable). For example, you might measure whether or not someone is smiling as a measure of happiness, or you might use a self-reported measurement where an individual rates on a scale of 1-10 how happy they are at that particular moment in time.
You might also want to use more sophisticated measures such as the Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS) or the PANAS (Positive and Negative Affect Scale) (Santos, 2018). (For more about how to find happiness and well-being, check out the Happiness lab to determine if you can find more direction here for fulfillment in your own life). Believe it or not, the difference in the type of measure you select can influence the results and the conclusions too! You want your measures to be both reliable – or consistent time and time again, and valid – or accurate in measuring what you intend to. Explore the concepts of reliability and validity below:
Launch in a separate window
Something to consider as you continue with your studies – particularly when you are trying to synthesize studies and compare results: Take time to write down some independent and dependent variables or measures that you might want to explore for your research topic of interest.
Developing Research Questions
Now that you have identified independent and dependent variables of interest, you are ready to begin developing a research question. Generally, a research question is a broad statement of what you want to inquire about and why it is important to do so. As you will learn this week, there are characteristics of ‘good†research questions you should know when creating a research question. These five characteristics of a good question are as follows:
the question clearly defines the variables of interest;
the question is falsifiable or testable;
the question is worthwhile or important to study;
the question clearly states the type of relationship that is expected; and
the question can be answered in one study (APA, 2020).
Figure 2
Characteristics of Good Research Questions
After a concise research question has been identified, with specific independent and dependent variables indicated, you will then want to include a null and an alternative hypothesis. The alternative hypothesis is what you expect to occur. It is like an answer that you are providing ahead of time to your research question. For example, you might hypothesize that the more time you spend lifting weights (independent variable), the better your physical fitness level will be as measured by your muscle mass (dependent variable). This is the alternative hypothesis or the effect you expect to observe. On the other hand, the null hypothesis states that there is no effect or impact of the independent variable (amount of time lifting weights) on the dependent variable (your muscle mass).
This week, you will be asked to select a true independent variable (not a quasi-independent variable) and a dependent variable of interest, develop a research question, and provide a corresponding null and alternative hypothesis based on what you expect to find. Pull up your sleeves, and get ready to dig in and get to work. You have a busy week ahead!
PSY-5107 Week 3 – Assignment: Develop a Good Research Question with Chosen Variables and Related Hypotheses References
Gravetter, F. J., & Forzano, L. B. (2018). Research methods for the behavioral sciences (6th ed.). Cengage Learning.
American Psychological Association. (2020). PsycLearn research methods [Computer software]. Author.
Santos, L. (2018). The Happiness Lab. Pushkin Industries.
Weekly Resources and Assignments
Review the resources from the Course Resources link, located in the top navigation bar, to prepare for this weekâ€s assignments. The resources may include textbook reading assignments, journal articles, websites, links to tools or software, videos, handouts, rubrics, etc.
